Which DSLR for a Beginner?

by Aaron on January 18, 2010

As a photographer, one question that I get asked frequently is which DSLR is a good choice for a beginner who wants to buy a camera. Although there’s not a single correct answer, here are some things to keep in mind.

Brand

I recommend either Canon on Nikon. Those two companies have something like 90% of the market share. While Sony, Olympus, and Pentax make good cameras, for someone who is likely to have a lot of questions, those questions will be easier to answer with a Canon or Nikon system. Either Canon or Nikon will produce great images… so which should you choose? I suggest that folks consider two factors. If you have existing SLR lenses, check and see if they’re compatible with Nikon or Canon’s systems. If they are, that’s a strong reason to stick with your brand. Another thing to consider is if your friends primarily use a given brand, it will be easier to get questions answered or possibly borrow lenses.

Price

Getting serious with photography with a DSLR is going to cost a significant amount of money. That said, I don’t advocate for a beginner to immediately drop a few thousand dollars on top-of-the-line gear. Before spending TOO much money, I recommend a more affordable system until one decides just how serious they’re going to be about their photography.

An important consideration is that when it comes to image quality, the lenses (casually referred to as “glass”) are as important, if not more important, than the camera body. Keep this in mind when budgeting for equipment. Don’t go buy a $2,000 body and then put on a $200 lens. My recommendation is to get one of relatively inexpensive “lower end” DSLRs to learn with, and get some decent lenses with the plan that the lenses will outlast the camera when (and if) you eventually upgrade to a fancier body in the future.

Key Features: Which Numbers Matter

This is going to contradict what a lot of retailers would like you to think, but megapixels are irrelevant. All of the DSLRs on the market have more than enough megapixels to create good-sized prints or enlargements, so unless you’re going bigger 16×20, don’t worry about the number of megapixels. All of the DSLRs will work in an automatic mode as well as allowing manual adjustments of things such as shutter speed, aperture, exposure compensation, and even ISO.

As you move up in price with DSLRs, you’ll gain better low light sensitivity, a faster frame rate (number of photos per second), more external buttons and knobs, and the option to record video.

For a beginner, the entry-level cameras will really teach you everything you need to know, and you won’t gain anything significant by moving up a level.

Where to Buy?

You’ll find the best deals online, but beware of too-good-to-be-true deals… there are a lot of shady folks that sell “gray market” imported cameras for what seem to be dirt cheap prices until you realize they’ll upsell you on all sorts of unnecessary accessories.

If you’re going to buy online, I recommend Amazon or B&H Photo.

If you’d like to get your hands on a camera and purchase from a retail establishment, talk with local photographers and find the best brick-and-mortar store in your area. I live near Portland, Oregon and really like Pro Photo Supply. A photography store with knowledgeable sales staff will give you a much better experience than a nationwide big box retailer.

Conclusions: What Should You Buy?

If you’re going to go Canon, my recommendation would be the Canon Digital Rebel XSi (Amazon, B&H). For Nikon shooters, take a look at the Nikon D3000 (Amazon, B&H). Either one of those options will give you a decent camera body with an 18-55mm starter lens for less than $600.

Get a camera and start taking photos. Either of the ones I recommended will take great photos, and despite what some equipment brand-zealots might tell you, the quality of photographs will depend far more on the technical and artistic talent of the photographer than the particular model of camera being used.

The links above represent my affiliation with vendors that I use and recommend. Purchasing via these links will result in me getting a (small) commission supports this site. Thanks!

These other posts might be of interest to you:

  1. Great Camera & Photography Deals for Father’s Day
  2. Pro Photographers Won’t Use In-Camera HDR
  • icelava

    At this stage of time, the current generation Rebel T1i / 500D is probably the model to look for instead of the older XSi / 450D.

  • ahockley

    I disagree… for someone just getting started, I don't think the additional
    features of the T1i (namely video) are needed or worth the price difference.

  • http://darkhax.com/ Daniel Huckstep

    I am quite happy with my Xsi. If I could buy something else today, I'd get the 50D, but I am past the beginner stage. My beginner stage was with a Ricoh SLR from 1979 (thanks dad!).

    My dad has the T1i, and it's pretty slick too. Any DSLR in that price range will more than suffice for any beginner.

  • http://musingmarc.blogspot.com IDisposable

    I think the Pentax K-x is the class winner. The camera is awesome, boots and shoots very fast. In-body anti-shake works with all lens. Great battery life and simple menu structure.

  • ahockley

    I haven't used one personally but I know a few happy Pentax K-x users. As I noted in the post, the size of the market share of Canon and Nikon means that for a newbie it's going to be a lot easier to find help or answers to questions if they're using a Canon or Nikon system.

  • dave.t

    great suggestions. I would also suggest that someone starting out spend ~$200 on a good 50mm “prime” (non-zoom) lens and another ~$200 on a good external flash. almost any flash that comes with the camera isn't worth beans.

  • http://thebananaverse.com/ verso

    Another consideration: Shooting film has a cost associated (developing). Shooting digital doesn't. Once you buy a nice big storage card for your camera, shooting on it doesn't cost anything extra. So shoot and shoot and shoot. This is what is helping me learn. I try to take note of what adjustments I make, and then I shoot the same picture with three different shutter speeds or with and without flash when I can, and adjust white balances up and down. This way I can compare the same photo with different settings so my most important tool – my eyes – can tell me what the differences are. For me this is by far the most effective teaching tool I have discovered. Remember: Nobody says you have to keep them all either!

  • http://viettelonline.com/ ThuanTM

    Oh thanks, i appriciate that!

  • Merielizza_metiong26

    So your old film SLR lense can be used for dslr? Thank you for a great post

Previous post:

Next post: